Rooster's Meat Barn

I have been here 3 times now and each time was as great as the first. Everything here is done from scratch and the animals used for the meats come from their own farm. Fresh homemade meats, soups, desserts, you name it...it's all done the right way here. First time here I had the pulled lamb sandwich. I had never heard of this before and I asked the owner what he suggested and after he said "everything", he said if I liked lamb then this was it. He couldn't be more correct. The lamb was tender and juicy, the roll was a nice sturdy Kaiser, and the pickled cabbage added a nice little acidity and juiciness to this sandwich as well. Next time in I ordered the "Phat Boy" and the Roast Beef sandwich. Both were incredible. The phat boy had fried eggs, cheese, pork roll (or Taylor Ham depending who you ask), bacon, and sausage on that same Kaiser roll. Everything was amazing, but the flavor of the sausage really shined through on this and created an experience I want over and over again. You could truly taste the freshness of the meat and delicious fennel flavor. This roast beef sandwich rivals (if not beats) the amazing roast beef sandwiches of my youth in Brooklyn from places like Brennan and Carr as well as Roll N' Roaster. The meat is incredibly tender, I was barely even chewing and it was just melting away in my mouth. The au jus added some nice flavor and moisture, and the horseradish mayo was (as it always is) a wonderful touch on a quality roast beef sandwich. The last time in (again on his suggestion) I went with the lamb burger. Another homerun. The meat was tender and cooked medium rare. The bun again was that same crusty Kaiser roll which I personally love for burgers. Just the addition of lettuce, tomato, and his Rooster sauce so to not overpower the flavor of the meat. This was seriously fantastic and somehow honestly probably the lowest on my list of items I loved here...that's how good everything else has been. Run, don't walk to get here. Roosters Meat Barn (I think technically in Reeders) in Stroudsburg, PA - Didn't Suck

I work for a local tow company and when I discovered roosters I have breakfast there at least once a week . The owner told me all his meats and eggs are from a farm and you can tell ! Everything I've eaten from there has been nothing less then amazing!!!

The best burgers we had in years! My kids had grilled cheese that were full of different types of cheese and were very good! And the chili fries were great. This is one of those places that you don't want to "judge a book by its cover." There is minimal parking, and it doesn't look great from the outside, but the inside it is great, and the staff is awesome! Note: they only accept cash but have an ATM inside. Glad we ate here. We will definitely go back.

After 2 years of them being in business, I finally stopped in, abd ut,was definitely worth ut.the food was delicious.the portions were generous. They had atypical beverages available, with their own brand of soda! The owner/ cook was accommodating, as we were served even though they were closing.the atmosphere was comfortable and fun.

The service here is amazing the women who greets you is so awesome. I would come here just for her kindness one of a kind for sure. Great food great bathrooms cash only. Bathroom has very very soft toilet paper which I like alot. Food is reasonably priced

Catered 2 large heros and cold salads for my son HS graduation. The portion was incredible, leftovers for days. Everyone raved about the food. The grandparents were raving how much it reminded them of what a NY hero looked like back in the day, “so thick it doesn’t your hand doesn’t fit around it “. Reasonably priced, the owner is a total gem, he genuinely enjoys his customers and knows them all by name. Love that the small town connection still exists. Thank you for helping me make a special day a total success

I just stopped in here a couple days ago and the owners where very nice!! I had gotten the stuffed cabbage soup and the rice pudding, it was very flavorful and tasty!! I would highly recommend coming to check this place out!